Is anyone else watching it?? I cannot get enough. I guessed the unicorn and raven correctly and I’m pretty positive I know who the Bee, Alien and Peacock are. I also think I know the lion. I have no idea about the monster, or rabbit. 

NOTE: Don’t post any spoilers for people who haven’t seen it!!!

The lions got me all sorts of confused!

Alright so I had no idea what this was until I saw this thread, but I looked it up and I'm watching the first episode now! I feel like I know who the peacock is. Will update with other thoughts. I'm pretty sure I know who the Monster is too.

I don't have cable so I haven't seen but a clip or two that's been sent to me! It looks so very interesting and I hoping it becomes able to be streamed soon!

I'm also pretty sure I know who the Alien is.

Con, you can stream it on Hulu.

omg! really?!? YAYYYY! I will hop on right after this episdoe of Gilmore Girls.

A good friend of mine has been nagging me to watch it for a while - I finally gave in. I am on episode 3

 I am 90% sure I know who the peacock is I knew the hippo. I knew the unicorn as well - not super getting into the guessing aspect, I just enjoy the charade - but I enjoy the whole show

Joe and I started watching it on Hulu and we got hooked. Joe guessed wrong on the hippo but got the Pinapple correct. Neither of us got the poodle. I told my mom about the show and now she's hooked too. We have like a family group message going on with a bunch of us all guessing who is who.

I also read that they already renewed for next season!

I almost got the pineapple! I thought it was the other half of the duo, haha.

Rabbit has got to be an NSYNC band member no hard proof for this one, but I feel it in my gut.

 After the 6th episode I do 100% know who the peacock is though - c:

I don't know, I think I might know who the Rabbit is and I don't think he's on N-Sync (which is what I originally thought).

My only guess for the rabbit was an NSYNC member... but I don't think it's a great guess. I really don't have any good clues for him.

It's not Adam Lambert but his stage presence reminds me of Adam Lambert.

I was thinking n'sync too, for the rabbit. I'm also 99% sure on who the peacock is now. ❤

WHO IS THE LION THO GUYS

Who is going to watch tonight!! Two people are getting revealed.

I think I have everyone figured out now. I'm 100% on the monster, lion, and bee and I'm 90% on the rabbit and the peacock.

I'll be watching it tomorrow when it gets released onto Hulu!
I played catch up and am hooked! Peacock, Rabbit, Bee, and Lion are my faves! No idea who anyone is, but the costumes are cool!

I did however guess correctly which character got voted to un-mask though! Does that count for anything? haha!

Knew the rabbit had to be a boy band xD his behavior was to uncanny..

also peacock... i still 10000% believe its Neil Patrick Harris... lol i watched him sing and dance in HIMYM 

1. I was a HUGE fan of Joseph & the technicolored dream coat (I performed as part of the Corus several times when I was younger) so I recognized the wig the peacock brought out instantly, as the wig Osmond wore when he preformed the play on broad way. However I knew 110 % who the peacock was when the angel Maroni tile showed up in his clues package. I don’t think that was ever recognized for what it was - but if you do know, it was a huge give away.
3. My gut knew the rabbit was N’sync.  I had kinda hoped that it was Chasez as he hasn’t been around much for a while it’d be a fun come back.... but kinda figured it’d be Fatone for the same reason. Plus the clues were obviously more related to Fatone.

i am excited for the next season. 

I'm so mad still that the rabbit was Joey Fatone! I was hoping it was a Whalberg, haha.

Also I originally thought the peacock was Billy Idol, but I was super on board with the Weird Al train at the end :P.

It’s coming back! 

The costumes this season are a bit ridiculous. Ice cream, tree ....... really? But that’s part of the reason we love the show right?

if Fox isn’t Jeremy Renner, and eagle isnt willie Nelson imma be real sad (those are just silly guesses with no substantial proof to back them up, so I don’t feel bad throwing them out there.) 

i do with 100% believe I know who thingamagig is though. That voice is pretty distinctive. I kinda wish they hadn’t shown singing portions on the preview

Okay, I'm watching the sneak peak right now! Will update if I have any thoughts on who is who!