Help > Graphics Critique & Questions > Post Reply     

Thoughts on Manip?

Default Avatar
Khaotic Mess
October 26th, 2022 1:19:38pm
4 Posts

Hello All!


I am recently getting back into HP after a long hiatus. I am starting to make manips again, but have no idea what things go for now. I wanted to make some premades, but wanted some guidance?


https://i.postimg.cc/fRP9sPhc/maegor.png


I made this for my GG stallion..... what is something along these lines worth?


Also open to any suggestions or critiquing. :)


Thank you all!!




 


View Comments 1


Player Avatar
ʜᴇʀᴇᴛɪᴄ
October 26th, 2022 2:17:08pm
986 Posts

Bumping for you!


Welcome back 💚




 

Player Avatar
Saturniaᛉ Check out my image contest!
October 26th, 2022 2:43:39pm
3,944 Posts

Welcome back!! I am by no means a graphic expert (That's Utakata, Ephemira, Amberellie, Dakiti, and many many others..) but I do enjoy giving my 2 cents! 

1. Love that background!! I used it for a manip that I did with a fox and it turned out so cute! 
2. Love that text font for the horses name - super cool! 
3. Your credits are a little off.. might wanna just check this guide here : https://horsephenomena.com/credithelp.php#da
4. Color for the credits is a little distracting.. might I suggest a subdued green and then to make it easier to read you can put a border on the text letters to help make it be legible without being distracting? 

Id say this could easily run around $40 mill ish? I'm not the best at gauging prices when it comes to them. But I think 40ish or so would be fair! 




https://i.ibb.co/cvNDrgC/SAT-footer

 

Player Avatar
utakata -✨-{main; dwbs}- - and that, love, was that
October 26th, 2022 3:30:02pm
1,540 Posts

Welcome back!


I really like this image, it's well set up and very clean/crisply done. I'd agree with Sat on maybe changing the crediting text, but other than that I don't have any critique really. I'd buy it ;)


Premades are a good way to get a sense of what the market is - that's how I went about figuring out prices for my work when I returned to HP last year. Sometimes not setting an autobuy and just letting people bid to see what the final price gets to can be a good indicator of how much you should be charging. I agree with Sat that I'd say definitely 40-50mill for images like that currently, possibly more depending on the market. Pop a couple up in the auctions, you might be pleasantly surprised!




forumsig.jpg

 

Default Avatar
Khaotic Mess
October 27th, 2022 6:29:51pm
4 Posts

Thank you all so much! I really appreciate the input :) I will check out the post and redo the credits, for sure!


 

Default Avatar
Jaya 40 [Belgian Sheepdogs]
October 27th, 2022 6:31:12pm
3 Posts

I think it looks great!




 

Default Avatar
Khaotic Mess
October 27th, 2022 7:06:56pm
4 Posts

Is this a little better? I tired the green with a white border, but it blended too much. I think that corner may just be too busy for credits


https://i.postimg.cc/Ls6h8g81/maegor.png




 

Player Avatar
Saturniaᛉ Check out my image contest!
October 28th, 2022 9:31:07am
3,944 Posts

Ooh I definitely think that's much better! 
That first one is a little difficult to read so potential ideas to fix that : 
1. Just bring that cluster of credits down a little! 
2. Line them horizontally kind of like a border at the bottom! 




https://i.ibb.co/cvNDrgC/SAT-footer

 

Default Avatar
Khaotic Mess
October 31st, 2022 8:39:52pm
4 Posts

Ah! That is such a good idea!!! Thank you!




 

View Comments 1