I tried searching and looking through the forums but didn't see this game. It's kind of like would you rather, but this or that? Can be literally anything (as long as it's appropriate, non-argumentative, and kind).

Example:

Person 1: Cats or Dogs

Person 2: Cats. 

Summer or winter?

I'll go first! 

Reading a series or watching a series?

“Life is short but also like terribly and insufferably long at the same time.” - Jenna Marbles

Raspberries 

Christmas or Valentines day?

Christmas

Pie or Cake?

Cake

Blueberries or strawberries?

Strawberries

mcdonalds or kfc?

KFC

Pizza or perogies?

Pizza

rural farm life or city life?

Rural farm life

Long drives or short drives?

Short drives

chicken dippers or fish fingers?

chicken dippers

Boat or jet ski?

Boat

flip flops or sandals 

Jet ski

Crayons or markers

markers

Pencil or pen?

Pen

Flip flops or sandals 

hmm the same thing?

but sandals I guess.

Greek yogurt or regular yogurt?

Normal yoghurt

crisps - salt vinegar or cheese onion?

ewww- neither. 

Strawberry or blueberry

blueberry

Yogurt or cereal?

depends...

butter in a stick or butter in a tub?

butter in a tub.

Horses or Pigs?

Horses

Milk or Coffee?