I tried searching and looking through the forums but didn't see this game. It's kind of like would you rather, but this or that? Can be literally anything (as long as it's appropriate, non-argumentative, and kind).

Example:

Person 1: Cats or Dogs

Person 2: Cats. 

Summer or winter?

I'll go first! 

Reading a series or watching a series?

“Life is short but also like terribly and insufferably long at the same time.” - Jenna Marbles

Milk, although I feel like I'm going against the grain with that one, oops LOL
Iced coffee is good every now and then but... I have milk wayyy more regularly!

Sweet or savory?
(And if I'm allowed... I'd vote savory myself, hehe)