HP Community > Forum Games > Post Reply
This or That?
![]() 𝓋𝑒𝓍𝒶𝓉𝒾𝑜𝓃 June 19th, 2023 2:55:40pm 736 Posts |
I tried searching and looking through the forums but didn't see this game. It's kind of like would you rather, but this or that? Can be literally anything (as long as it's appropriate, non-argumentative, and kind).
Example: Person 1: Cats or Dogs Person 2: Cats. Summer or winter?
I'll go first!
![]() |
View Comments < Prev 1... 5 6 7 8 9 ... 11 Next >
![]() Lynelle! ♔ Limited Access Dec 19-30th August 2nd, 2025 10:30:22pm 2,978 Posts |
ooo... both? but if it's not iced coffee...
then... hot tea
wet socks or dirty/oily hair? |
![]() MagicFlame August 3rd, 2025 5:19:10am 3,125 Posts |
Omg no to either but would choose wet socks drink only water and nothing else forever or eat a bag of spinach everyday forever 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() Lynelle! ♔ Limited Access Dec 19-30th August 3rd, 2025 9:34:20pm 2,978 Posts |
Oh I love water and I love spinach. But spinach.....
Would you rather never shave again or you're waxer burns you every day? |
![]() MagicFlame August 4th, 2025 3:26:20am 3,125 Posts |
Never shave again would you rather walk the same boring 4 mile loop everyday without fail or have to wake at 4am to go swimming for a hour everyday 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() Lynelle! ♔ Limited Access Dec 19-30th August 10th, 2025 4:58:21pm 2,978 Posts |
ummm.... probably walk.
I love swimming.. a ton - but not waking up at 4am
Would you rather have a missing finger or toe? |
![]() Eyre ♡ August 10th, 2025 10:21:22pm 10,408 Posts |
Finger, my balance already sucks with 10 toes so I think I'd be extra unlucky with 9 toes. itch from mosquito bites or poison ivy rash ![]() |
![]() binx ‹𝖒𝖆𝖎𝖓› ✧ faroese horses -- lotus, stardust and captain jack sparrow for mascot 2026 ♡ August 15th, 2025 2:01:16pm 6,796 Posts |
itch from poison ivy rash Read your favourite series or binge watch your favourite series? |
![]() MagicFlame August 15th, 2025 6:06:51pm 3,125 Posts |
Binge watch eat 5 vegetables or eat 5 fruits 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() shadow fox [k n a b s t r u p p e r s] August 16th, 2025 2:49:30pm 471 Posts |
veggies. i love the fruit but don't love having to take insulin for its generally higher carb content xD tacos or quesadillas? |
![]() MagicFlame August 16th, 2025 6:05:50pm 3,125 Posts |
Quesadillas salty popcorn or sweet popcorn? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() Lynelle! ♔ Limited Access Dec 19-30th August 17th, 2025 10:38:25pm 2,978 Posts |
Buttered? Would that be sweet?
(but also, not a big fan of popcorn...)
Talking on the phone or emails? |
![]() MagicFlame August 18th, 2025 5:05:53am 3,125 Posts |
Talk on the phone horses or ponies? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() shadow fox [k n a b s t r u p p e r s] August 19th, 2025 1:15:34pm 471 Posts |
horses pepperoni pizza or cheese pizza? |
![]() MagicFlame August 20th, 2025 4:20:21am 3,125 Posts |
Cheese pizza tuna sandwich or chicken sandwich? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() binx ‹𝖒𝖆𝖎𝖓› ✧ faroese horses -- lotus, stardust and captain jack sparrow for mascot 2026 ♡ August 20th, 2025 5:07:38pm 6,796 Posts |
chicken sandwitch chocolate or something sweet |
![]() MagicFlame August 20th, 2025 5:17:27pm 3,125 Posts |
Something sweet normal tooth brush or electric? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() binx ‹𝖒𝖆𝖎𝖓› ✧ faroese horses -- lotus, stardust and captain jack sparrow for mascot 2026 ♡ August 20th, 2025 5:35:30pm 6,796 Posts |
normal tooth brush horses or dogs? |
![]() MagicFlame August 20th, 2025 5:42:49pm 3,125 Posts |
Horses cinema or bowling? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |
![]() binx ‹𝖒𝖆𝖎𝖓› ✧ faroese horses -- lotus, stardust and captain jack sparrow for mascot 2026 ♡ August 20th, 2025 5:44:49pm 6,796 Posts |
cinema hot chocolate or coffee? |
![]() MagicFlame August 20th, 2025 5:46:15pm 3,125 Posts |
Hot chocolate light colours or dark colours? 👻 nothing to see here 👻 |







